Do you have to be a believer to answer paranormal questions?
If so why is this section under science and mathematics
So many great answers, it is hard to choose.
Answer by Feeling Mutual
No.
Mathematics is a philosophy, not a science.
Numbers do not exist in reality.
Answer by kumorifox
Not necessarily. I think this is placed here to get a scientific take on things, as well as believer answers.
Answer by NorCalJRC
I don’t think that you have to be a believer to answer questions about the paranormal. You do however need to approach your answers with a critical mind and skeptics are really what make the paranormal so interesting.
I am a believer, I have seen enough, and conducted my own “investigations” and I know that there is something out there, something is happening… and maybe someday we’ll see what can be considered “proof”.
I think that this category is a little misplaced, many of the believers don’t really want it in the science category, and the skeptics/scientists are someone annoyed that its taking up space in here.
In any case, those who don’t believe are simply giving another perspective in a field that needs more and more every day.
Anyone know why paranormal questions are categorized under science?
Surely they should be under religion, pseudoscience or mental health.
Answer by TR
Well, I don’t agree about being under mental health. I think the vast majority of paranormal experiences can be explained by our senses being tricked, or perhaps fear, anxiety, faith belief, poor investigative/analytical methods, or power of suggestion. These are all typical of the normal human condition. I think mental illness can practically explain only a very tiny part of it.
I personally think that it would be well placed under “Society & Culture”. I appreciate it when scientific explanations for paranormal or parapsychological phenomenon are sought, but that seems a rarity despite being in the Science category. But the reason why Yahoo placed it here is linked below.
Answer by Fancy That
paranormal phenomena is real. It has been observed, recorded, caught on Video take and experiences by millions of people. With the advent of technology, we are now capable of detecting more and more of the elusive energies than at any time in history.
I won’t ask you to accept that ‘paranormal’ activity has any specific religious or spiritual significance (that is up to the individual to decide to for themselves). But to deny that paranormal phenomena occurs is simply not consistent with the empirical evidence that is available.
Answer by Kev
It is the job of science to go into the unknown. You are free to believe that we are born, live and die – full stop. A lot of people don’t and there are significant measurements and evidence around that something is going on. The paranormal science go beyond what we can easily see, touch, taste, smell and hear to explore the questions of a deeper reality.
CHECK OUT www.daremattg.com and follow for updates!!! Music by www.youtube.com WOOT DARE MATTG 3! I took the best dares and questions from the last dare mattg .. and guess what.. I DIDDEMMMMM HARDDDDDD So anyway let me know what you think by leaving a comment and liking the video! :3 If you want to see more leave a comment or video response with your dare or questions! This week.. you meet a homeless ghost that I let stay with me, we explore my nipples, We learn HOW TO PLANK!, I speak with a crazy british accent, take you on a date, go to tim hortons, do my hair.. with tape… make out with my cat, flip some tables in anger and SO MUCH MORE! I LOVE YOU ALL! All my social networking SEND ME STUFF MattG124 PO Box 24116 301 OXFORD ST W. London ON Canada N6H5C4 MERCH: www.districtlines.com Join my online community! www.mattg124.com Email me Mattg124films (AT) gmail.com Snuggie Cat Facebook Group bit.ly Almost daily videos here!! www.youtube.com www.MattG124.com Facebook www.facebook.com Myspace: www.myspace.com Twitter: twitter.com Dailybooth: dailybooth.com Stickam www.stickam.com Googleplus: www.gplus.to
Posts Related to Do you have to be a believer to answer paranormal questions?
Paranormal Questions?
Paranormal Questions? Hi, I really got a surprise the other day. I have been going to Mythology and Folklore for all things Paranormal. Then one ...
Why do people who don’t believe in paranormal answer questions just to tell the asker they are stupid?
Why do people who don't believe in paranormal answer questions just to tell the asker they are stupid? If you don't believe in the paranormal ...
-
Q&A: Would anyone like for me to ask any paranormal questions on Hot ParaTalk’s Radioshow?
Would anyone like for me to ask any paranormal questions on Hot ParaTalk's Radioshow? On tonights show we are having a Debate tonight; Non-Believers vs. ...
-
Do questions about the paranormal increase after ghost hunting shows air?
Do questions about the paranormal increase after ghost hunting shows air? Are these shows causing people to wonder about the possibilities, or using the power ...
Q&A: Paranormal questions ? ? ?
Paranormal questions ? ? ? Questions: Do you believe in Paranormal? Do you believe in ghosts and/or spirits? Do you believe in demons? Do you ...
Personally I don’t think paranormal phenomena should be under any other category. I think it should be on its own, with additional sub categories such as mythology, metaphysics, astrology, and possibly even alternative therapy, energy work etc.
I also think “mathematics” would be better served under “homework” rather then in science as well.
But ultimately it would have been practically impossible for the creators of Yahoo categories to come up with a system that would please everyone. So we all need to just accept the categories being where they are, and work within that frame as best we can.
I hope that helps.
http://ca.answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=Ahvd873JpulBsUvniOt7xsXBFQx.;_ylv=3?qid=20090321230619AAIignU&show=7#profile-info-qEdhPD8Laa
http://ca.answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AoyvcQ_fecGYkdw1fd7Cy9vBFQx.;_ylv=3?qid=20090323100634AAZm1g6
http://ca.answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AgEQAsPXTQgtiuAeWM6xRRvBFQx.;_ylv=3?qid=20090219141501AAvaHBd
http://ca.answers.yahoo.com/question/answer?qid=20090408064616AAbzu6l
Because it has been shown time and time again there is scientific proof for some “paranormal” phenomenon. Scientists all over the globe are studying these things. Check the questions above, there is so much documentation.
Bravo, NorCal, Bravo. I realize this isn’t how it works, but I vote you for best answer.
No, but it sure helps. Years ago, I would’ve scoffed at this section, relegating it to the ‘Elvis sightings’ category, but after a few vivid, non-drug-induced paranormal encounters, I’m not only a believer, but I’m looking for answers. Science is the methodical study of God’s handiwork, and it would seem there is more to be explained than we have answers for. I’d like to be part of the world of research as it pertains to to this fascinating branch of life-studies.
No, i’m just doing this for fun.
I hope not,otherwise I’m in trouble.The quickest way to get a skeptic to answer your question.Tell them not to answer.I see a lot of questions way too silly for me to answer.Then there it is,no skeptics.I can’t resist throwing in my 2 cents.Just to make a point,”it’s an open forum”.
Certain people are dogmatic or fanatical in their belief of the paranormal so they don’t want to be bothered by any answer that doesn’t fall in line with their personal belief system. Others just take the short cut and block anyone whom they don’t agree with.
Personally, I think all people should be able to iterate and defend their beliefs in a public forum. No belief or belief system should be sheltered from public scrutiny. If you have a belief you should be able to say exactly what it is and why you believe in it.
lol This is an old “battle” on here. It’s not our fault that the Paranormal Section is attached to Science and Math. We’ve asked to have it moved. Guess Yahoo thinks it has something to do with Science or Math. Sorry. Yes..you can answer questions on here. You’ll notice that many skeptics post their opinions. They’re not really “answers”..just opinions. Once in awhile they’ll give a good natural explanation. I always appreciate those answers.
I am a paranormal researcher and do not believe in ghosts – this is because ghosts have never been proved to exist under scientifically controlled conditions.
People tend to base their beliefs on their own personal experiences which is fine – but anyone who is a researcher in any field of research knows testimonals cannot stand alone as proof.
No, you certainly don’t. Yahoo originally placed Paranormal under Science & Mathematics because they felt that some scientific methods were used to study the paranormal (see link). Unfortunately, Yahoo’s intent of fostering scientific discussion of the paranormal never materialized and instead this area is used by believers mostly for Q&A on ghost stories, angels and demons, prayer and spirit guides, ouija boards, crystal energy and other types of religious belief or folklore. You’ll notice that many believers post their opinions. They’re not really “answers”, just opinions.